Wednesday, July 4, 2012

Using Pluggable Authentication Modules (PAM)

Pluggable authentication modules are a common framework for authentication and security. Understanding and using PAM can be very beneficial for planning and implementing a secure, efficient single sign-on solution.

About PAM

Programs that grant users access to a system use authentication to verify each other's identity (that is, to establish that a user is who they say they are).  In Red Hat Enterprise Linux, many programs are configured to use a centralized authentication mechanism called Pluggable Authentication Modules (PAM).
PAM uses a pluggable, modular architecture, which affords the system administrator a great deal of flexibility in setting authentication policies for the system. PAM is a useful system for developers and administrators for several reasons:
  • PAM provides a common authentication scheme that can be used with a wide variety of applications.
  • PAM provides significant flexibility and control over authentication for both system administrators and application developers.
  • PAM provides a single, fully-documented library which allows developers to write programs without having to create their own authentication schemes.

PAM Configuration Files

The /etc/pam.d/ directory contains the PAM configuration files for each PAM-aware application.

PAM Service Files

Each PAM-aware application or service has a file in the /etc/pam.d/ directory. Each file in this directory has the same name as the service to which it controls access.
The PAM-aware program is responsible for defining its service name and installing its own PAM configuration file in the /etc/pam.d/ directory. For example, the login program defines its service name as login and installs the /etc/pam.d/login PAM configuration file.

PAM Configuration File Format

Each PAM configuration file contains a group of directives that define the module and any controls or arguments with it.
The directives all have a simple syntax that identifies the module purpose (interface) and the configuration settings for the module.
module_interface control_flag module_name module_arguments

PAM Module Interfaces

Four types of PAM module interface are available. Each of these corresponds to a different aspect of the authorization process:
  • auth — This module interface authenticates use. For example, it requests and verifies the validity of a password. Modules with this interface can also set credentials, such as group memberships or Kerberos tickets.
  • account — This module interface verifies that access is allowed. For example, it checks if a user account has expired or if a user is allowed to log in at a particular time of day.
  • password — This module interface is used for changing user passwords.
  • session — This module interface configures and manages user sessions. Modules with this interface can also perform additional tasks that are needed to allow access, like mounting a user's home directory and making the user's mailbox available.


An individual module can provide any or all module interfaces. For instance, provides all four module interfaces.
In a PAM configuration file, the module interface is the first field defined. For example:
auth    required
This instructs PAM to use the module's auth interface.
Module interface directives can be stacked, or placed upon one another, so that multiple modules are used together for one purpose. If a module's control flag uses the sufficient or requisite value, then the order in which the modules are listed is important to the authentication process.
Stacking makes it easy for an administrator to require specific conditions to exist before allowing the user to authenticate. For example, the reboot command normally uses several stacked modules, as seen in its PAM configuration file:
[root@LinuxHowtoServer ~]# cat /etc/pam.d/reboot
auth    sufficient
auth    required
#auth   include        system-auth
account required
  • The first line is a comment and is not processed.
  • auth sufficient — This line uses the module to check whether the current user is root, by verifying that their UID is 0. If this test succeeds, no other modules are consulted and the command is executed. If this test fails, the next module is consulted.
  • auth required — This line uses the module to attempt to authenticate the user. If this user is already logged in at the console, checks whether there is a file in the /etc/security/console.apps/ directory with the same name as the service name (reboot). If such a file exists, authentication succeeds and control is passed to the next module.
  • #auth include system-auth — This line is commented and is not processed.
  • account required — This line uses the module to allow the root user or anyone logged in at the console to reboot the system.

 PAM Control Flags

All PAM modules generate a success or failure result when called. Control flags tell PAM what do with the result. Modules can be stacked in a particular order, and the control flags determine how important the success or failure of a particular module is to the overall goal of authenticating the user to the service.
There are several simple flags, which use only a keyword to set the configuration:
  • required — The module result must be successful for authentication to continue. If the test fails at this point, the user is not notified until the results of all module tests that reference that interface are complete.
  • requisite — The module result must be successful for authentication to continue. However, if a test fails at this point, the user is notified immediately with a message reflecting the first failed required or requisite module test.
  • sufficient — The module result is ignored if it fails. However, if the result of a module flagged sufficient is successful and no previous modules flagged required have failed, then no other results are required and the user is authenticated to the service.
  • optional — The module result is ignored. A module flagged as optional only becomes necessary for successful authentication when no other modules reference the interface.
  • include — Unlike the other controls, this does not relate to how the module result is handled. This flag pulls in all lines in the configuration file which match the given parameter and appends them as an argument to the module.


The order in which required modules are called is not critical. Only the sufficient and requisite control flags cause order to become important.
There are many complex control flags that can be set. These are set in attribute=value pairs; a complete list of attributes is available in the pam.d manpage.

PAM Module Names

The module name provides PAM with the name of the pluggable module containing the specified module interface. The directory name is omitted because the application is linked to the appropriate version of libpam, which can locate the correct version of the module.

PAM Module Arguments

PAM uses arguments to pass information to a pluggable module during authentication for some modules.
For example, the module uses information stored in a Berkeley DB file to authenticate the user. Berkeley DB is an open source database system embedded in many applications. The module takes a db argument so that Berkeley DB knows which database to use for the requested service. For example:
auth    required db=/path/to/BerkeleyDB_file
Invalid arguments are generally ignored and do not otherwise affect the success or failure of the PAM module. Some modules, however, may fail on invalid arguments. Most modules report errors to the /var/log/secure file.

Default PAM Configuration

The following PAM modules are implemented in the PAM libraries on UnixWare: Their functions and arguments are the same as documented in the PAM System Administrator's Guide, except as noted below.
Console Module
Implements the "CONSOLE" and "USERS" defaults feature for login. See login(4). Not implemented in Linux-PAM.
Locking Out Module
Returns an authentication failure.
Dialup Password Module
Implements /etc/dialups, /etc/d_passwd  authentication. 
FTP Module
Implements Anonymoous FTP Authentication (i.e., prompts for an email password.)
Last Login Module
Maintains the /var/log/lastlog file.
List-File Module
Denies or allows services based on an arbitrary file.
Mail Module
This module looks at the user's mail directory and indicates whether the user has any mail in it.
No Login Module
If /etc/nologin exists but is empty, the message Logins currently disabled is returned and access is denied.
Promiscuous Module
Returns authentication success.
rhosts Module
Provides authentication as described on rhosts(4), as used by rlogin, rsh, and similar utilities.
Root Access Module
Provides root access without requiring a password.

UNIX Password Module
The following options are always enabled:
  • bigcrypt
  • likeauth
  • nis
  • nodelay
  • shadow
If pam_unix was not used to authenticate (e.g. rsh command), the pam_unix account management function skips all password expiration checks.
If the nullok option is not set for the account management function, and the authenticating user has no password, the module returns PAM_NEW_AUTHTOK_REQD (same as if password was expired). This is needed to implement the login PASSREQ and MANDPASS features.
Warning Logger Module
Logs information about a proposed authentication or password update.
The following system utilities and applications are PAM-enabled:
  • cups 1.1.19-02
  • dtlogin
  • dtsession
  • ftpd
  • login
  • mail (pop and imap)
  • passwd
  • rlogind
  • rshd
  • rexecd
  • samba 3.0.4
  • sshd
  • su
  • telnetd
  • xlock

Sample PAM Configuration Files

sample PAM application configuration file:
Simple PAM Configuration
auth           required
auth           required nullok
auth           required
account        required
password       required retry=3
password       required shadow nullok use_authtok
session required

  • The first line is a comment, indicated by the hash mark (#) at the beginning of the line.
  • Lines two through four stack three modules for login authentication.
auth required — This module ensures that if the user is trying to log in as root, the tty on which the user is logging in is listed in the /etc/securetty file, if that file exists.
If the tty is not listed in the file, any attempt to log in as root fails with a Login incorrect message.
auth required nullok — This module prompts the user for a password and then checks the password using the information stored in /etc/passwd and, if it exists, /etc/shadow.
The argument nullok instructs the module to allow a blank password.
  • auth required — This is the final authentication step. It checks whether the /etc/nologin file exists. If it exists and the user is not root, authentication fails.


In this example, all three auth modules are checked, even if the first auth module fails. This prevents the user from knowing at what stage their authentication failed. Such knowledge in the hands of an attacker could allow them to more easily deduce how to crack the system.
  • account required — This module performs any necessary account verification. For example, if shadow passwords have been enabled, the account interface of the module checks to see if the account has expired or if the user has not changed the password within the allowed grace period.
  • password required retry=3 — If a password has expired, the password component of the module prompts for a new password. It then tests the newly created password to see whether it can easily be determined by a dictionary-based password cracking program.
The argument retry=3 specifies that if the test fails the first time, the user has two more chances to create a strong password.
  • password required shadow nullok use_authtok — This line specifies that if the program changes the user's password, using the password interface of the module.
    • The argument shadow instructs the module to create shadow passwords when updating a user's password.
    • The argument nullok instructs the module to allow the user to change their password from a blank password, otherwise a null password is treated as an account lock.
    • The final argument on this line, use_authtok, provides a good example of the importance of order when stacking PAM modules. This argument instructs the module not to prompt the user for a new password. Instead, it accepts any password that was recorded by a previous password module. In this way, all new passwords must pass the test for secure passwords before being accepted.
  • session required — The final line instructs the session interface of the module to manage the session. This module logs the user name and the service type to /var/log/secure at the beginning and end of each session. This module can be supplemented by stacking it with other session modules for additional functionality.

Use of module

This PAM module authenticates users based on the contents of a specified file. For example, if username exists in a file /etc/sshd/ssh.allow, sshd will grant login access.
How do I configure module to deny access?

You want to block a user, if user-name exists in a file /etc/sshd/sshd.deny file.

Open /etc/pam.d/ssh (or /etc/pam.d/sshd for RedHat and friends)
# vi /etc/pam.d/ssh

Append following line:
auth required item=user sense=deny file=/etc/sshd/sshd.deny onerr=succeed

Save and close the file

Now add all usernames to /etc/sshd/sshd.deny file. Now a user is denied to login via sshd if they are listed in this file:
# vi /etc/sshd/sshd.deny

Append username per line:

Restart sshd service:
# /etc/init.d/sshd restart

Understanding the config directives:
auth required : Name of module required while authenticating users.
item=user : Check the username
sense=deny : Deny user if existing in specified file
file=/etc/sshd/sshd.deny : Name of file which contains the list of user (one user per line)
onerr=succeed : If an error is encountered PAM will return status PAM_SUCCESS.
How do I configure module to allow access?

You want to ALLOW a user to use ssh, if user-name exists in a file /etc/sshd/sshd.allow file.
Open /etc/pam.d/ssh (or /etc/pam.d/sshd for RedHat and friends)
# vi /etc/pam.d/ssh

Append following line:
auth required item=user sense=allow file=/etc/sshd/sshd.allow onerr=fail

Save and close the file.

Now add all usernames to /etc/sshd/sshd.allow file. Now a user is allowed to login via sshd if they are listed in this file.
# vi /etc/sshd/sshd.allow

Append username per line:

Restart sshd service (optional):
# /etc/init.d/sshd restart

Now if paul try to login using ssh he will get an error:
Permission denied (publickey,keyboard-interactive).

Following log entry recorded into my log file (/var/log/secure or /var/log/auth.log file)
tail -f /var/log/auth.log

Jul 30 23:07:40 p5www2 sshd[12611]: PAM-listfile: Refused user paul for service ssh
Jul 30 23:07:42 p5www2 sshd[12606]: error: PAM: Authentication failure for paul from 125.12.xx.xx

Understanding the config directives:
auth required : Name of module required while authenticating users.
item=user : Check or specify the username
sense=allow : Allow user if existing in specified file
file=/etc/sshd/sshd.allow : Name of file which contains the list of user (one user per line)
onerr=fail : If filename does not exists or username formatting is not coreect it will not allow to login.

1 comment: